SCE (Safety Critical Element) identification is the process of determining and classifying equipment, systems, or structures that are essential for preventing major accidents or limiting their impact in high-risk industries like oil and gas.
What are safety-critical elements and performance standards?
Safety Critical Elements (SCE): These are components or systems that play a crucial role in controlling and mitigating major accident hazards (e.g., fire suppression systems, emergency shutdowns).
Performance Standards: These are the criteria used to ensure that safety-critical elements perform effectively under specified conditions, defining their required functionality, reliability, availability, and survivability.
Importance of Process Safety Management (PSM)
Process Safety Management (PSM) focuses on identifying, preventing, controlling, and mitigating the unintended release of hazardous materials that could lead to catastrophic incidents such as fires, explosions, and mass injuries.
The Role of Safety Critical Elements in Risk Management
The Swiss Cheese Model illustrates the role of Safety Critical Elements (SCEs) in system integrity. Each layer of defense (or SCE) has potential weaknesses (holes). When these weaknesses align, it can lead to accidents. Strong performance standards are essential to ensure these barriers remain effective and prevent system failures.
Swiss Cheese Model illustrating the role of Safety-Critical Elements (SCEs) in preventing system failures
Why is SCE Identification Important?
Identifying Safety Critical Elements (SCEs) and performance standards ensures that new installations comply with best engineering practices and maintain reliability throughout their lifecycle.
Aging installations: Continuous monitoring and performance management help prevent major accidents and ensure ongoing safety.
Methods for Identifying Safety Critical Elements
SCE identification is based on Process Safety Management (PSM) systems, Hazard and Effects Management Systems (HEMS), and risk assessments. The identification process includes:
Step 1: Identify Major Accident Events (MAEs)
Different hazard identification techniques help in recognizing potential MAEs:
Review the list of Major Accident Events (MAE) developed in HAZID.
Identify systems linked to each MAE.
Assess the criticality of each system based on potential failure impact.
Categorize systems as safety critical for integrity or control and mitigation.
Step 3: Categorization of Safety Critical Elements
SCEs are classified into two categories:
Integrity-based SCEs: Prevent accidents by ensuring system integrity.
Control and Mitigation SCEs: Respond to and minimize the impact of incidents.
How to Develop Performance Standards for SCEs
The FARSI model is commonly used to develop Safety Critical Element Performance Standards:
Functionality: Defines the role of the SCE in preventing or mitigating hazards.
Availability: Determines how often the SCE needs to function.
Reliability: Assesses the likelihood of the SCE performing when required.
Survivability: Evaluates how the SCE performs post-accident.
Interaction: Examines dependencies between SCEs.
Performance standards are documented in:
Hazard Registers or Risk Registers
Hazard and Effects Management Registers
Major Accident Hazard (MAH) sheets
SCE Identification & Performance Standards: Assessing System Criticality for MAE Prevention
The SCE Identification Process Using the Bowtie Model
SCE identification is often conducted through Bowtie Analysis, a structured approach that visually links accident causes, preventative barriers, and mitigation measures.
Key Steps in the Bowtie Workshop:
Multidisciplinary teams assess facility equipment and diagrams.
Identify SCEs that prevent or mitigate MAEs.
Categorize safety and environmental critical elements (SECEs).
Justify why certain elements are not considered safety-critical.
Implementing Performance Standards for Safety Critical Elements
Once an SCE is identified, its performance is measured based on:
Functionality and reliability requirements.
Defined performance standards aligned with design codes and regulatory standards.
Maintenance, inspection, and testing schedules to ensure compliance.
Ongoing performance monitoring using safety registers and operational safety cases.
Corrective actions if deviations occur from expected performance.
Conclusion: The Importance of SCE Management
Key Takeaways:
Safety Critical Elements (SCEs) are essential in preventing and mitigating major accident hazards.
Identifying and categorizing SCEs ensures compliance with engineering best practices.
Performance standards define functionality, reliability, availability, and survivability.
Ongoing monitoring, testing, and maintenance are crucial for effective SCE lifecycle management.
By integrating SCE identification, performance standards, and lifecycle management, industries like oil and gas can enhance process safety, reduce risks, and maintain regulatory compliance.
Contact us for expert SCE Identification, Performance Standards, and Risk Management Services in Oman.
Elixir Engineering is a multi-disciplinary Engineering services company. With our strong technical team, we have proven to be effective for our Clients.
Contact Form
Use this form to contact our team. We usually respond within 24 hours but it can take longer on weekends and around public holidays.
