elixir-engineering-logo
Register

BowTie Analysis Services in Oman

Introduction

BowTie Analysis is a proven risk assessment and risk communication technique used to identify, understand, and manage major accident hazards (MAH). It visually demonstrates how hazards can escalate into critical events and how preventive and mitigative barriers control these risks.

Elixir Engineering Oman provides structured, practical, and regulator-aligned BowTie Analysis services to Oil & Gas Operators, EPC Contractors, Power Plants, Chemical Facilities, and Industrial Projects across Oman and the GCC.

What is a BowTie Model?

The BowTie Model is a visual diagram that clearly illustrates the relationship between:

  • Hazards
  • Threats
  • Top Event (loss of control)
  • Consequences
  • Preventive and Mitigative Barriers
  • Escalation Factors and Controls

It supports effective risk understanding at all organizational levels, from management to frontline operations.

How BowTie Analysis Works

BowTie Analysis represents risk as a logical sequence:

Hazard → Threats → Top Event → Consequences

Barriers are placed on both sides of the top event:

  • Preventive barriers stop threats from leading to the top event
  • Mitigative barriers reduce the severity of consequences

This approach helps answer key safety questions:

  • What can go wrong?
  • Why can it happen?
  • How is it prevented?
  • How are consequences controlled?

BowTie Analysis Methodology

Our BowTie studies focus on clarity, consistency, and practical risk control rather than excessive complexity. The objective is to clearly demonstrate how major accident hazards are controlled through effective preventive and mitigative barriers.

Key Steps in BowTie Analysis:

  • Identify the hazard
  • Define the top event (loss of control)
  • Identify credible threats leading to the top event
  • Identify potential consequences following the top event
  • Define preventive barriers to stop escalation
  • Define mitigative (recovery) barriers to limit consequences
  • Identify escalation factors that could weaken barriers
  • Define controls to manage escalation factors

BowTie Analysis Methodology – Practical Application

BowTie analysis diagram illustrating hazard, threats, preventive barriers, top event, consequences, and mitigative controls for process safety risk management.
Typical BowTie Analysis diagram showing threats, preventive barriers, top event, consequences, and mitigation controls for a major accident hazard.

The BowTie diagram illustrates a typical major accident hazard scenario, where a pressurized Crude Oil storage tank represents the hazard and loss of containment is defined as the top event. The left side of the diagram shows credible threats such as process deviations, corrosion, mechanical failure, and human or procedural issues, along with preventive barriers including design basis, operating procedures, control systems, alarms, relief systems, and management of change.

The right side of the diagram presents potential consequences such as pool fire, oil spillage, environmental damage, and asset loss. Mitigative barriers such as fire and gas detection, emergency shutdown systems, secondary containment, and emergency response measures are shown to reduce consequence severity. Escalation factors affecting barrier performance are identified on both sides and managed through appropriate controls.

The completed BowTie diagram provides a clear and transparent overview of risks, barriers, consequences, and barrier vulnerabilities.

Escalation Factors and Barrier Vulnerability

Escalation factors are conditions that can degrade barrier effectiveness, such as:

  • Poor maintenance
  • Human error
  • Inadequate procedures
  • Environmental conditions

Each escalation factor is linked with specific controls to maintain barrier performance and reliability.

Barrier Performance Assessment

Each safety barrier is evaluated for:

  • Barrier type (engineering, procedural, human, organizational)
  • Supporting management systems (procedures, training, standards)
  • Ownership and accountability
  • Effectiveness and reliability

This ensures alignment with asset integrity, process safety, and Safety Management Systems (SMS).

BowTie Study Team

A BowTie Analysis is conducted through structured workshops with a multidisciplinary team, typically including:

  • Project / Design Engineer
  • Operations or Production Manager
  • Process / Chemical Engineer
  • Maintenance Engineer
  • Electrical Engineer
  • Instrumentation Engineer
  • HSE Representative

A competent Lead Facilitator ensures consistency, technical accuracy, and compliance with industry best practices.

How BowTie Risk Assessment is Used

Step by Step Application:

  1. Define the hazard and top event in clear language
  2. Identify all credible threats
  3. Identify realistic consequences
  4. Validate cause event consequence logic
  5. Assess preventive barrier effectiveness
  6. Assess mitigation measures
  7. Identify safety critical actions and responsibilities
  8. Identify and prioritize safety critical equipment

BowTie Analysis Example

For example, a heavy object stored at height represents a hazard. If support fails (top event), the object may fall, causing injury or damage (consequences). Bow-Tie Analysis identifies barriers to prevent the fall and controls to reduce injury severity.

Benefits of BowTie Analysis

  • Clear and structured hazard identification
  • Supports ALARP demonstrations
  • Improves visibility of safety critical barriers
  • Enhances workforce risk awareness
  • Supports risk based decision making
  • Helps prioritize safety improvements

BowTie Barrier Model

  • Preventive barriers: Stop threats before loss of control
  • Mitigative barriers: Limit consequence severity

Barrier effectiveness is continuously reviewed and linked to the Safety Management System.

Software Tool

Elixir Engineering utilizes BowTieXP, an Industry recognized software tool for Bow-Tie development, barrier management, and performance tracking.

BowTie Study Deliverables

  • BowTie Terms of Reference (ToR)
  • BowTie Worksheets
  • BowTie Diagrams
  • BowTie Analysis Report

Applicable Standards & Guidelines

Our BowTie Analysis services align with:

International Standards

  • ISO 31000 – Risk Management
  • ISO 45001 – Occupational Health & Safety
  • ISO/IEC 31010 – Risk Assessment Techniques

Industry Guidance

  • IOGP Report 456 – BowTie Risk Management
  • OGP Report 415 – Managing Major Incident Risks
  • CCPS (AIChE) Risk-Based Process Safety Guidelines
  • UK HSE HSG 65
  • ICAO Safety Management Manual
  • Dutch Standard NTA 8620

Conclusion

BowTie Analysis is a powerful visual tool for managing operational and process safety risks. By clearly linking hazards, threats, barriers, and consequences, organizations can effectively protect people, assets, and the environment.

Need BowTie Analysis Services in Oman?

Elixir Engineering Oman delivers practical, compliant, and industry aligned BowTie Analysis studies for Oil & Gas, Power, Chemical, and Industrial facilities.

Contact us today for reliable BowTie risk management support in Oman.

Elixir Engineering

Elixir Engineering is a multi-disciplinary Engineering services company.
With our strong technical team, we have proven to be effective for our Clients.
Contact Form
Use this form to contact our team. We usually respond within 24 hours but it can take longer on weekends and around public holidays.
Contact Form
crossmenu